Permitting reform and purpose collapse in the United States

As you guessed, I’m not American, but I am interested in the debate in America over the “Bipartisan Affordability and American Jobs Act” (BAAJA) act, a move to ease environmental regulations and restrictions on large-scale energy infrastructure. It’s currently the subject of debate (and which has already leapt over several hurdles on the way to potentially being passed).

I’m not going to litigate its details, but a fair few people I trust have found the bill will worsen greenhouse gas emissions, permanently remove crucial environmental protections, hasten a fossil-fuelled data centre boom, and do very little for energy affordability (if anything, it might make it worse).

What I’ve been thinking about is how it represents something more significant, in the sidelining or even outright removal of climate action as a priority or concern for a huge swathe of clean energy, climate and environmental organisations. I don’t think it’s unique to America, and I don’t think it should be ignored.

The decay of clean power’s moral purpose

Something I think maybe many people don’t realise is that during Trump’s two-year tenure so far, America’s growth in electricity demand has mostly been served by the energisation of new wind, and new solar. I’ve seen this sort of celebrated as a ‘win’ that flies in the face of Trump’s agenda. That may be, but I’m not sure it’s counter to the fossil fuel industry’s agenda.

Clean growth is better than demand growth being met by fossil fuels. But what about the existing coal and gas on America’s grid? They’ve both actually increased slightly, meaning the country’s power grid emissions have stagnated since 2020 and grown since 2023. This is an important dynamic: renewable energy growing fast, while emissions rise at the same time:

This is a sort of clean/fossil truce: renewables get the demand growth, but coal and gas linger and even slightly grow. CEOs on both sides feel victorious, and the only losers are…..everyone inside Earth’s heating atmosphere.

Climate writer Bill McKibben said this to the New York Times recently:

“[BAAJA] is plenty good enough for people in the clean energy industry, as they can live with and prosper under a regime where you’re steadily increasing the amount of clean energy, even if you’re increasing, or at least not quickly decreasing, the amount of fossil energy”

Bill really has shot a very precise arrow into the the heart of this problem. The head of the US Solar Energy Industries Association, SEIA, is a former Republican politician. From what I can see essentially all SEIA’s recent statements regardless of topic make a point of not mentioning climate change.

Pawlenty has jumped between positions, but at one point in 2011 was an outright, old-school full-throated climate denier:

You can see now why a solar power lobby, led by the guy above, might be perfectly fine with solar panel sales going up even while the overall grid’s pollution continues to ratchet higher (interestingly, Australia’s increasingly gas-friendly “clean energy council” hired a climate-denying right-wing radio host at the last election). You don’t have to look hard to find examples of warm admiration of this strategy from political journalists.

What we can see here though is that removing climate as a priority very simply means no one is interested in trying to bring down greenhouse gas emissions. Climate targets, progress checks and shifting projections are all so 2010s. Removing this as a thing people care about and work on results in rising volumes of person-killing pollution being released. More people die or get hurt, or live more uncomfortable lives.

It is worth noting the reason for growing demand in the US: at least half, if not a comfortable majority, of America’s power demand growth comes from data centres, and much of that comes from AI applications.

What this means is that where there still is clean energy infrastructure growth in America, it is servicing what I’d still bet is the single most universally loathed technological shift in human history. Compare this to the project of climate action, which remains broadly supported even in the US:

It is fair to worry that the red-hot toxicity of data centre development may bleed over into anti-renewable sentiment. What is important to acknowledge is that this is 100% the fault of data centre developers and clean energy developers, both of whom are sacrificing public support and moral purpose for some greasy instant gratification.

Taking all of the power lines, wind turbines, solar panels, transmission lines, batteries, distributed energy, demand response, grid management technologies, geothermal and hydro and diverting them towards something detested will spread public detestation all over all clean tech, too. It is already happening.

Move fast, break nothing, and keep both until the day you die

It’s worth asking whether deregulation, fast-tracking and slashing environmental protections actually really helps renewables get built. Wind, solar and transmission in particular are dispersed over a lot of land, by design. Some take that to mean they require unchecked environmental destruction to grow, but I see it as a sign that they can only grow with consistent, smart and constructive environmental regulation and multi-decade, deeply rooted and hard-earned community support.

As I wrote in the piece above:

“It is because climate action is so urgent that we should be careful with how we roll out clean energy. If you are worried about climate impacts, you should worry about how to ensure the growth of wind and solar doesn’t occur in a self-sabotaging and destructive way. We need speed, yes, but we also need to maintain speed. Sacrificing the latter to achieve the former results in failure”

In that piece, I lay out how this happened in Norway, which flipped from one of Europe’s highest wind power development rates in 2019 to essentially zero for every year after 2021. It’s a mix of reasons, including breaching the rights of the Sámi reindeer herders, Norway’s deeper climate denial and fossil fuel support, and an environmental ideology that is sometimes tuned to be sensitive to visual presence more than material environmental disruption (consider how different we treat cabin development to renewable development). But ultimately, all these things could have been managed with a more careful, well-planned growth pathway.

You can really see a Norway-wind-power-effect playing out with data centre development around the world: there’s no end to news reports of intense public opposition and cancelled projects. “Move fast and break things” tends to break things.

You can imagine how the blatantly self-destructive “speed to power” headspace of tech and data centres has already begun to cause damage to the solar and wind industries. This is a really crucial moment, and both the wind and solar industries have to choose which project they’re part of. Far too many of them are choosing to push a sneering middle finger in the face of society alongside big tech and data centre developers.

The US is set for an era of worsening grid emissions

Much of the debate over the bill has been around whether it reduces or worsens emissions. The only analysis released with full assumptions and transparency was written by Kevin J Kircher, of Purdue University. Other organisations, like Greenline Insights and the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, Resources for the Future (RFF), and Rhodium Group found the bill would reduce emissions relative to a world in which it wasn’t passed. But as Kircher highlights, those models miss something crucial:

“If a world with BAAJA has higher electricity demand than a world without BAAJA, then BAAJA causes additional electricity-sector emissions unless clean sources supply at least 100% of the induced electricity demand”

Part of the reason for the lack of transparency feels to me like a desire to avoid the bigger picture in the US: the power grid is, in the context of a bloated and fossil-fuelled AI boom, is set to see emissions grow whether BAAJA is passed or not.

RFF admit this in a chart buried down in their analysis:

This is the power sector – the sector that’s meant to be the easiest, and most guaranteed to see its emissions drop thanks to clean technology growth. In one of the richest countries on the planet. You can see this essentially confirmed in the IEA’s latest WEO:

That’s billions and billions invested into grids and clean power in the next ten years, and all of it fails to reverse an increase in the total use of fossil fuels and an increase in power sector emissions in the US.

This is why it is so bad that “meeting growing demand for data centres / AI” has become such catch-cry among clean energy companies and lobby groups. It is a formal announcement of a departure from climate priorities. To be clear: offering 100 solar farms to a tech company doesn’t reduce the amount of fossil fuels that tech company is going to build. They very literally have an infinite hunger for energy, en route to their machine god.

Something else worth noting is the idea that the US has a connection queue mostly comprised of renewable energy. The logic goes that broad, technology-neutral deregulation will result in mostly clean energy being built. This was maybe true back in 2024, but in 2026, the volume of potential gas generation has overtaken renewable energy, according to my own analysis:

Open the tap in 2026, and half of what you get will be more fossil fuels. The idea that the ‘free market’ will always opt for cheap clean energy isn’t true because there has never really been a free market. Big tech desperation, corruption, environmental rollbacks and right-wing ideology all skew the balance towards fossil fuels.


It is odd to see this play out right when COP31 stalls due to a lack of agreement around whether to mention fossil fuels. Many of the players that put on a big show of objecting to exclusion of fossil fuels are going to fly back home and continue the project of climate hushing (UK, EU, Norway, Australia et al).

But climate change doesn’t stop when you stop talking about it. The atmospheric physics governing the dangerous trapping of excessive heat in the walls of the home we’re locked inside do not change when we pivot to energy security.

What this moment calls for, as unnatural as it may feel, is for a return to a loud and unchecked dedication to stopping the extraction and combustion of fossil fuels. Hoping for this to happen as a side-effect of unchecked AI and energy expansion is obviously doomed to fail. Tactically feigning a forgetting of climate for strategic and PR reasons always results in people and groups actually forgetting about climate change. The only way out of this hole is to remember that fossil fuels kill people, and we don’t want people to die.

  1. A group I’ve supported is opposed to BAAJA for many reasons. They are the Water Protector Legal Collective (WPLC): an Indigenous-led non-profit law firm and advocacy organization that works to protect the rights of Indigenous Peoples and Original Nations, the Earth, and climate justice movements. In case you’re interested, they have a webinar on Tuesday, Nov 24. It’ll unfortunately be quite late for you (7 pm U.S. ET, so 1 am CET Wed Nov 25). Register for the webinar: tinyurl.com/BAAJAupdate
    Their website: https://www.waterprotectorlegal.org/

Leave a Reply